Top Ten Reasons Franz Family Get-Togethers were often like the First Thanksgiving
** This is another post from my archives. I wrote it when I was writing a garden blog for the Metro DC area. Definitely one of my favorite jobs of all time. It was from November 2010 and I updated it quite a bit for this current post. It is meant as a playful post and I’m sure it has some (or many) historical inaccuracies. I’m posting it mostly for my relatives in the Franz family and the great memories we made at Dutch and Dorothy’s home in Michigan. BUT, I have also included links to a lot of great resources about the REAL first Thanksgiving.
I love Thanksgiving for many reasons. First, it’s one of only two holidays that encourage most people to take time out from their busy lives and get together with their families. Second, it’s all about being thankful, something that many people forget to do on the other days of their lives. But third, in the Franz family, it was also about sharing gardening and cooking secrets – which is really what the first Thanksgiving – way back in November 1621 – was all about.
Tom and I always loved spending Thanksgiving in Michigan, where most of his family lived. Thanksgiving morning often started with a walk through the vegetable garden, with sister-in-law Dorothy showing off her fall vegetables and letting us pick our favorites. In my opinion, Dorothy is the best gardener of the family – the one that can get anything to grow. And I wouldn’t be surprised if some of her techniques actually started at that first Thanksgiving, thanks to a Native American named Squanto.
If you don’t know about Squanto, he is often mentioned in stories about the first Thanksgiving. There are conflicting stories about what really happened on the first Thanksgiving but most of the stories agree on the basic details:
In September of 1620, 102 pilgrims set sail for the New World aboard a ship named The Mayflower. Although their intended destination was Virginia, strong winds and storms forced them to settle in the area of Plymouth.
They had a brutally harsh first year and many of them didn’t live to see their first New England Spring.
The ones that did, however, were surprised when an English speaking Indian named Samoset visited them. According to writer Bill Heid *, in his e-book, Squanto’s Garden, (which no longer seems to be available) Samoset’s first words to the Pilgrims were:
“Welcome, English. I am Samoset. Do you have beer?” The Pilgrims were surprised but glad to accommodate Samoset’s request, as they had brought beer with them on the voyage. In fact, they had brought nine times more beer than water, because beer was much more potable. This might strike many of us as strange who have been taught that the Pilgrims were hard, straight-laced folk; but the reality is that they were a lively group that worked hard, played hard and prayed hard. *
Several days later, Samoset returned with another Native American named Tisquantum (often called Squanto). Since Squanto spoke English, his role was to act as interpreter between the Native Americans and the Pilgrims. However, his importance to the Pilgrims was much greater than that. Squanto taught them to garden.
The Pilgrims did not know how to survive in this new land but as a native, Squanto did. He taught them which plants were poisonous and which had medicinal powers. He taught them how to plant corn by heaping the earth into low mounds with several seeds and putting a dead fish in each mound to help fertilize the corn. He also taught them to plant other crops and how to tap the maple trees for sap.
In November 1621, The Pilgrims had much to celebrate, they had built homes in the wilderness, they had raised enough crops to keep them alive during the long coming winter, they were at peace with their Native American neighbors. They had beaten the odds and it was time to celebrate.
So they decided to have a feast. The guests at the feast included the 52 remaining pilgrims and about 90 Native Americans. One of the historical conflicts is about whether the Indians were actually invited or whether they just showed up when they heard all of the gun shots from the Pilgrim men who were out trying to shoot some food for the feast.
The celebration lasted for three days. While no record exists of the historic banquet’s exact menu, it is believed that the meal included fowl (possibly turkey, duck and swan), venison, corn, pumpkins, squash and freshly caught seafood such as lobster, eel, crab and cod.
Since this post was originally written for a garden blog, I didn’t really delve into the authenticity of some of these facts but I shared a lot of info in the resources section below. And this is a quote I like from Bill Heid from one of the articles in that section:
So this Thanksgiving, whenever you gather… around a big farmhouse table, a small off-grid cabin counter, or even by yourself with a simple meal… remember Squanto. One of America’s greatest heroes. Remember the quiet man who turned tragedy into generosity, who turned strangers into neighbors, and who taught America its first lesson:
No one does it alone. And no one is meant to. ~ Bill Heid
For more about the history of Thanksgiving, see the Resources links below.
And for a little pre-holiday laugh, here are the:
Top Ten Reasons Franz Family Get-Togethers were often like the First Thanksgiving.

10) Travelers came from miles around to join in the feast.
9) Like Samoset, the first question that many of the visitors would ask was “Do you have beer?”
8) The menfolk would often spend the week before the feast hunting for meat to put on the table.
7) Venison would often be included as part of the three day feast.
6) Meals always included freshly picked, home-grown vegetables from the garden.
5) The celebration would last long into the night and celebrants would sit around a fire.
4) The first Thanksgiving feast lasted for three days. We would eat leftovers and continue celebrating for at least three days.
3) “Between meals, the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag (Indian Tribe) played games. The Wampanoag might have taught the English the Pin Game, where a player tried to toss a small ring onto a pin.” We would play similar games, either horse shoes or darts, depending on the weather.
2) “Besides sports, there was also singing and dancing among both the Wampanoag and the Pilgrims.” Many times, at least one of the wild men or women at our gathering would break into song or dance.
And the number one reason that our Thanksgiving Celebrations were like the original Thanksgiving?
1) With all of the challenges we may have faced during the year, we still had much to celebrate and we always remembered to give thanks.
Click here to Further Reading & Historical Resources :
-
- Off the Grid News – Squanto: The Hero Who Proved America Was Never A Solo Survival Project
- Plimoth Patuxet Museums — Who Was Tisquantum (Squanto)? — Detailed history of Tisquantum’s transatlantic journey and role at Plymouth, told alongside Wampanoag perspectives.
- Pilgrim Hall Museum — The First Thanksgiving — Features the original 1621 eyewitness accounts written by Edward Winslow and William Bradford.
- History.com — Who Was Squanto and What Was His Role in the First Thanksgiving
- Yale University Press – The Real History of Squanto and Mayflower-Indian Relations
- From Google Gemini:
-
The
*after Samoset and the Pilgrims drinking beer:-
Samoset asking for beer: Verified directly in the 1622 primary source Mourt’s Relation (written by Edward Winslow and William Bradford). Samoset walked into Plymouth on March 16, 1621, said “Welcome, Englishmen!” and asked for beer—the colonists gave him strong water (spirits) and food instead, as they were running low on beer by March.
-
Bringing more beer than water: Verified in William Bradford’s Of Plymouth Plantation—beer was standard shipboard rations because water fouled in wooden casks during long ocean crossings. (Only the “prefab pub” detail was likely an embellishment from Bill Heid’s e-book.)
-
-
The
***after the games, singing, and dancing (#3 and #2):-
Games and “exercising of arms”: Primary eyewitness Edward Winslow wrote in Mourt’s Relation that during the three-day gathering, the English colonists “exercised our arms” (held military drills/marksmanship demonstrations) and both groups engaged in “recreations.” Traditional Wampanoag games like the pin-and-ring game (tossing a bone or wood ring onto a sharp pin attached by a cord) and hubbub (a bowl-and-dice game) are well-documented in 17th-century New England records (such as William Wood’s New England’s Prospect, 1634), which is why museum educators at Plimoth Patuxet routinely highlight them when describing what games were played in 1621.
-
Singing and dancing: Both English harvest festivals and Wampanoag autumn thanksgiving ceremonies (Nickommo) traditionally centered on communal singing, drumming, and dancing, which is also noted in historical reconstructions of the 1621 gathering.
-
Leave a Reply